New Jersey casino workers recently faced disappointment as their efforts to implement a total ban on indoor smoking in their workplaces were dismissed by a judge. Despite their claims of unsafe working conditions and long-term health issues due to second-hand smoke exposure, the judge ruled that employees could choose to work in smoke-free environments if they desired.
The lawsuit sought to end the loophole that allows smoking on 25% of the casino gaming floors, while all other workplaces in the state have a complete smoking ban in place. Workers argued that this exemption created risks to their health and safety, but the judge maintained that the limited number of industries exempt from the ban did not infringe upon individuals’ rights to pursue safety.
Although the ruling was a setback for the casino workers, the fight is not over yet. The Casino Association of New Jersey President, Mark Giannantonio, expressed his desire to find a solution that addresses workers’ concerns while also protecting the industry. He warned that a total smoking ban could lead to a significant drop in revenue and job losses for the casinos.
Thousands of casino workers supported the lawsuit, with plans to appeal the decision to the New Jersey Supreme Court. They expressed disappointment in being exposed to toxic second-hand smoke daily and criticized the prioritization of the casino industry over their health.
Efforts to pass legislation closing the smoking loophole have faced challenges, with a key proponent of the bill withdrawing support last year. This prompted legal action from Casino Employees Against Smoking Effects and Region 9 of the United Auto Workers in April. Similar bans are being pursued in other states like Virginia, Kansas, Pennsylvania, and Rhode Island.
Not all casino workers supported the smoking ban, with UNITE HERE Local 54, the largest casino workers union in the state, backing the lawsuit dismissal due to concerns about potential job losses. Governor Phil Murphy, a defendant in the lawsuit, had previously committed to signing smoking ban legislation if it reached his desk after legislative approval.
The complex issue of indoor smoking in New Jersey casinos highlights the challenges faced by workers seeking a healthier work environment. Despite the setback in court, the fight continues as workers push for a ban on indoor smoking to protect their health and well-being.